Dark Souls received positive from critics upon its release. One of the reviewers for Dark Souls described it as “a very hardcore dark-fantasy [role-playing game]” that is “role-playing right down to the roots,” and stated that the “massive field map and powerful enemies serve to rev up both your sense of adventure and your sense of dread.” Another reviewer stated that “the sheer happiness you get after the trial-and-error pays off and you overcome the challenge is absolutely impossible to replicate.”
GameSpot scored Dark Souls a 9.5/10. Much praise was given to the online system, as well as the sense of jubilation felt when conquering boss fights after numerous failed attempts. They also suggested that casual gamers may struggle to progress, whereas role-playing game enthusiasts will thrive on the difficulty.